Hiding Out in the Open: Researching LGBT Ancestors

aunt mary and friend

Each week I receive the following type of genealogy-related research request via email:

  • “My great aunt Rose seemed to disappear right after World War II and the family never heard from her again. Family members have mentioned in hushed tones that she was a lesbian and living with another woman on the West Coast.”
  • “I think my grandfather may have been a homosexual. There were always rumors about him, even though he was married to my grandmother for over 50 years.”
  • “My cousin Teddy lived most of his life with another man who was listed in his obituary as a longtime companion. How do I find out more about their relationship?”

So, why do I seem to receive these questions? Perhaps because I’m a self-identified (aka “out”) gay man active in the genealogy community and it makes sense that others seek me out for my research advice and input for clues. Over the years I have prepared my own “guide” to researching the lives of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgendered) people, and in honor of National Coming Out Day tomorrow, October 11th, I’m sharing my knowledge here for other researchers.

First Things First: What Exactly Is “The Need to Know?”

Does it really matter that you or a client know more about a gay ancestor and that person’s activities? What value could such information add to the overall information about that ancestor? For those of us seeking an entire picture of the person we research using genealogy-related records, details as to sexuality and lifestyle do matter, especially if they had an impact on major life decisions including employment and relationships.

I believe the pursuit of such information is valid for another reason: future generations of genealogists may become so accustomed to personally knowing self-identified homosexuals, they also may take the existence of same sex marriages for granted, etc. . . . that they won’t know what to look for when it comes to older records. Even now, the younger generation seems to take much about LGBT lifestyles for granted. Often they don’t understand what it was like to live and act and talk in “Code” as a means of survival or that there were life and death consequences to being “outed.”

If you are committed to serious research involving a possibly gay ancestor, take time to consider how you’ll use the information and how the information will be shared. I don’t necessarily believe there is a proper way to “out” a gay aunt or bisexual uncle; in fact, I think it is a matter of presentism creeping into one’s research that makes many believe a relative would identify themselves as homosexual if they were alive today. Unless you yourself identify as a LGBT person, it is difficult to understand all the issues involved with daily life “in the closet” or the impact of “coming out.” Outing your gay ancestor may not be the best way to preserve that person’s memory, let alone share family history with your living relatives.

Next: Understand Gay History

Before you try to research various records, either in person or online, do some basic background reading on the history of LGBT people in the United States. Many people—even members of the gay community—are unaware of “queer history” and how it shaped their community and impacted the history of the United States. Here is a glimpse at some more recent history:

  • World War II played an important role in gay history. During the war, men and women normally turned away from military service for being gay were pressed into service in order to help win the war.
  • Between 1939 and 1945, large numbers of gay men and women who lived in isolation in rural areas had the opportunity to interact with others who were “just like them” thanks to military service.
  • Look at current locations with large gay populations: San Francisco, New York, San Diego, Chicago, and Philadelphia. They were all important military installations during World War II. Many in the military may have seen their service end in these cities and simply stayed there and became part of the community.
  • The military witch hunts of homosexuals returned once the war was over. Pair this with the rise of McCarthyism and the Lavender Scare and you begin to understand why talking and behaving under a “Code” continued to develop as a means of keeping a job or interacting with other LGBT folk.
  • In most places, homosexuality was a crime; those suspected of being “queer” or “different” could lose their jobs and be shunned by their families.
  • Prior to the 1950s, very few LGBT people lived an “out” lifestyle or were open about a long-time relationship with another member of the same sex. Such information was only shared with a close group of friends, and possibly sympathetic relatives. It is difficult to find evidence of “out” individuals through public records.
  • The “bar culture” was a huge part of the social world of gay men and women, and in many cities, such as New York, bars were controlled by the Mafia or other crime syndicates. Gays were often extorted for money or blackmailed. Police officers were paid off to look the other way when it came to gay bars. When a raid did happen, it often resulted in some bar patrons having their names, addresses and occupations published in the newspaper.
  • The Stonewall Riots in June 1969 are considered a watershed moment in gay history. Taking place in Greenwich Village in New York City, Stonewall at its core was a rejection of the status quo when it came to how LGBT people were treated by society. Led by a group of drag queens during yet another police raid on the Stonewall Inn bar, the anniversary of the Stonewall Riots is marked annually on the last Sunday in June as Gay Pride Day.

In the post-Stonewall era, the gay rights movement started. Over the subsequent four decades advancements have been made in terms of rights concerning marriage, adoption, and employment for LGBT people.

The Code and Subcultures

I use the term “Code” or “The Code” to designate slang, terminology and code words that one learned as they navigated the various subcultures in the LGBT culture. Since homosexuality was illegal and being “outed” had many ramifications in terms of employment and societal integration, a secret language or argot developed among gays and lesbians. For example: Polari is a slang language developed in Britain and used by gays as well as performing artists, criminals, prostitutes and others living on the margins of society. Polari as a language has roots as far back as the 16th century and is still in use today; many practitioners say it is an “attitude” more than a language. Today’s “Code” is marked by phrases, vocabulary and gestures some of which have made it into mainstream culture thanks to greater acceptance of LGBT people, especially as portrayed by the media.

As with many underground cultures, various LGBT subcultures developed over time. Studying and knowing the differences between the gay male culture, the lesbian culture, the transgender culture, etc. is vital to “decoding” information, especially in personal letters and diaries. Some of these subcultures, to the outsider, are often seen as “deviant” or tend to reinforce stereotypes about gays and lesbians. Put aside your preconceived notions when investigating a subculture. As with any reference material, take note of items that can later help you locate information about a gay ancestor.

Understanding language related to gay life can offer many clues when looking at records or reviewing personal letters and diaries. The same holds true for the various queer subcultures: many had their own Code, their own practices and even their own symbols and forms of dress.

Know Your Gayborhoods

Many of our immigrant ancestors flocked to specific neighborhoods when they arrived in America. The reason? They felt safer with those who spoke their language and kept the same customs as in the Old World. These neighborhoods in large urban areas often had strict dividing lines and offered a “step up” on the path to becoming an American citizen and being successful.

The sense of belonging in a geographical sense was, and to some extent is, still true for gay men and women. Certain districts in cities such as New York (Greenwich Village) and San Francisco (The Castro) are where newcomers would settle in order to be closer to the LGBT culture. Again, don’t fall victim to presentism when it comes to noting the “gayborhood” in which an ancestor may have lived. Research what was designated as the gay ghetto during your ancestor’s time in that location. For example, The Castro was not a predominantly gay neighborhood until the early 1970s; prior to that time the Polk Gulch area is where you would find bars, bookstores and other LGBT hangouts and where your ancestor may have lived.

Queer Work: Occupations Offer Clues

On one of my recent research requests, my client noted that her uncle was a hairdresser by trade and asked, “Why are so many male hairdressers also gay?” What may not be apparent to “straight eyes” are the realities of earning a living for many homosexuals.

You could be (and can still be) fired for being gay in many locations in the United States. For that reason, many homosexual men and women earned a living as small business owners – florists, hairdressers, etc. – where they were the boss and they knew they would not be fired based on their sexuality. In addition, certain professions, such as working in a barber shop or hair salon, were “portable,” which meant you had little inventory (a good set of barber tools) and could pick up and find work in another city if needed.

There were specific professions—in the art and design fields, for example—where you could meet other gay men and women. In department stores, males behind the counter were “salesmen”, but were often called “ribbon clerks” as part of gay slang. Look for bars near these large stores as places for socialization after work. Often on census sheets, you’ll see the general term “artist” used as opposed to “set designer” or “interior decorator” or “fashion designer.”

In some cases, the partner of a gay man or woman might be listed as an employee such as a “private secretary” or “assistant” and listed under the head of household. In addition, the place of employment would be listed as “in a private home” or “for a private family.”

‘Til Death Do Us Part

One sad fact you’ll discover as you research LGBT ancestors, especially those who lived in committed relationships, is this: after death, many of them were buried separately or with their family due to the family’s wishes or due to poor estate planning. Keep in mind that from a legal standpoint “blood” trumped “friendship,” even when that friendship had endured 30, 40 or 50 years or more. Some couples planned and ensured that their final wishes were respected in terms of burial locations, disposal of assets, etc.

As for clues, code words often used in obituaries could indicate that the decedent was a homosexual. These include “lifelong bachelor,” or “survived by siblings,” and “no immediate survivors.” In addition, if the person was in a long-term relationship, the term “longtime companion” or “devoted friend” would be used. Prior to the late 20th century, rare was the death notice that would list the surviving partner as a “partner,” or a “lover,” or “spouse.”

Mementos and Items Left Behind

On rare occasions, I’ve worked with clients who inherited from their gay ancestor a group of letters, diaries or even small collections of items such as match book covers and ticket stubs to plays and performances. Read letters and diaries and remember “the Code,” and look for specific occupations as well as geographical locations that were historic gay neighborhoods.

One client who scanned several matchbook covers didn’t realize they were from local gay bars that her uncle may have frequented. “How do you know?,” she asked; I knew from having researched the local watering holes which catered to gay men and women. Many had names incorporating a color and an animal, such as “Black Cat” or “Blue Parrot” which was Code to out-of-town gay visitors that it was a “safe space.” For those unacquainted with the “bar culture” in the LGBT community, realize that these bars were more than just places where you could get a drink and meet someone: they often acted as social clubs and places where gay rights meetings were held and marches or protests were planned.

So what might look ordinary to you when it comes to belongings may require further research with an eye toward LGBT culture, subcultures and history.

Apply the FAN Club Strategy

The best success in determining that an ancestor may have been gay, bisexual or transgendered is to rely upon the FAN Club approach: tracing Friends, Associates and Neighbors of the person in question. Remember that LGBT folk often lived in the same neighborhood, may have run in the same social circles, and often worked in specific fields and occupations.

And before you ask, no there is no such thing as a “gay record.” Despite rumors of some of us carrying a “gay card” and risking its loss due to nonconformity with a subculture’s rules (like a gay male being enamored of Broadway musicals), researchers need to build a body of LGBT knowledge to be successful in locating records which may indicate that a person was a homosexual.

  • Starting with the 1940 US Census, the term “partner” could be used to indicate someone living in the household that was not a blood relation. More likely you’ll see “boarder” or “roomer” used.
  • Look for occupations on military records and census records that represent “queer work” as described above.
  • Passenger lists, especially for steamship travel in the early 20th century, may show two people living at the same address.
  • Check the address listed in voting registers, city and telephone directories and even census schedules – does it fall within a traditional gay neighborhood?
  • Again, in census schedules, note children of adult age who are unmarried or a married couple showing no history of children.
  • Military discharge records, especially if the discharge was less than honorable, can hold important clues as well.
  • Passport applications can offer clues. With no children of their own, some gay men and women had more disposable income and tended to travel more. On passport applications check the identity of the person verifying that the applicant is a US citizen and that they have known that person for a specific amount of time. Often, this person has a FAN Club connection to your ancestor.
  • Newspapers are a good source of obituary and death notice information. In addition, and unfortunately, any arrests of homosexuals would be detailed, and sadly, as front page news in some communities.

Examples of LGBT Research and Records

One of the best ways to illustrate using records which may offer clues to being part of the LGBT culture is to research historical figures either self-identified as gay and lesbian or who are generally accepted by historians as being gay.

  • Movie director Dorothy Arzner (1897–1979) produced several well-known films during the 1930s and 1940s, including Clara Bow’s first talkie, The Wild Party. Arzner is often linked romantically with choreographer Marion Morgan (1881–1971). A New York Passenger List dated 5 April 1933 lists both Arzner and Morgan sharing the same home address, 2249 Mountain Oak Drive, Hollywood, California. Source: Manifest, Monarch of Bermuda, 5 April 1933, List 2, p. 55, for Dorothy ARZNER (age 36), digital images, New York, Passenger Lists, 1820-1957, digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com: accessed 6 October 2014).

ARZNER 1933 Pass List

  • Jobyna Howland was an actress and a model for Charles Dana Gibson’s Gibson Girl in the early 20th century. While she was said to have had a lesbian affair with the playwright Zoë Akins, a 1930 US Federal Census sheet shows her living with “friend” Germaine Gerard, a French divorceé, in the Alto Nido Apartments in Los Angeles, California. Source: 1930 U.S. Census, Los Angeles County, California, population schedule, Los Angeles, Enumeration District 64, p. 37A (penned), dwelling 207, family 493, Jobyna HOWLAND, digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com: accessed 6 October 2014); from National Archives microfilm publication T626, roll 134, image 445.0.

HOWLAND Jobyna 1930 US Census

  • Costume designer Travis Banton was active from the 1920s through the 1950s and created memorable fashions for stars such as Betty Grable, Mae West, Claudette Colbert and more. While no evidence of a long-term relationship with another man could be found, Banton’s occupation was always listed as “artist” instead of dress or costume designer. In addition, reading between the lines on an Emergency US Passport Application as to how a passport was lost offers clues that Banton may have been a homosexual. Source: Affidavit attached to Emergency U.S. Passport Application, dated 7 January 1921, by Travis BANTON made at Paris, France, U.S. Passport Applications, 1795-1925, digital images, Ancestry (http://www.ancestry.com: accessed 6 October 2014), National Archives and Records Administration, Emergency Passport Applications, Argentina thru Venezuela, 1906-1925, ARC 1244183, Box #4560, Volume #176, p. 217.

BANTON Travis 1921 Emer US Passport 03

* * *

Conclusion: Things Were Different Then

The term homosexual was not in use until 1869 (coined by Hungarian journalist Karl-Maria Kertbeny). What you and I understand in the 21st century when it comes to how LGBT people identify themselves today would likely be foreign to many LGBT people prior to the 1940s.

Living in a “marriage of convenience” was part of being in the LGBT subculture. Working in certain professions was a given. So was knowing “the Code” and passing that knowledge on to others new to the LGBT community. Looking back at how our gay ancestors lived may, in fact, make some of us feel pity for them. We may express sadness in knowing that they took certain actions based on strict societal expectations. Again, we can’t accurately compare how LGBT individuals in the past lived with members of today’s LGBT communities.

What we can do is this: try to accurately research all aspects of their lives and when discovering evidence of a lifestyle outside of the expected norm of their time, preserve the information and determine if it truly adds to the entire picture of their lives. And then add it and make it available for future generations of researchers.

Resources

  • Baker, Paul, Fantabulosa: A Dictionary of Polari and Gay Slang, London: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2004.
  • Berubé, Allan, Coming Out Under Fire: The History of Gay Men and Women in World War II, Chapel Hill: Univ of North Carolina Press, 2010.
  • Cante, Richard C., Gay Men and the Forms of Contemporary US Culture (Queer Interventions), Farnham (United Kingdom): Ashgate Publishing Co., 2008.
  • Chauncey, George, Gay New York: Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay Male World, 1890-1940, New York: Basic Books, 1994.
  • Duberman, Martin, Stonewall, New York: Open Road Media, 2013.
  • Gates, Gary J. and Jason Ost, The Gay & Lesbian Atlas, Washington, D.C.: Urban Institute Press, 2004.
  • Lifshitz, Sebastien, The Invisibles: Vintage Portraits of Love and Pride. Gay Couples in the Early Twentieth Century, New York: Rizzoli, 2014.
  • Katz, Jonathan Ned, Gay American History: Lesbians and Gay Men in the U.S.A., New York: Plume (Penguin Group), 1992.
  • Mann, William J., Behind The Screen: How Gays and Lesbians Shaped Hollywood, 1910-1969, New York: Penguin, 2002.
  • Stryker, Susan, Transgender History, Berkeley: Seal Press, 2008.

©2014, copyright Thomas MacEntee. All rights reserved.

Help Us Find the Owner of this Grave Marker

manin templeton grave marker

The grave marker shown above has been located on a run down property in Portland, Oregon during a renovation. Your help is needed in understanding more about the marker and hopefully return it to the family of the persons listed on the marker.

Grave Marker Details

Francis Day Manin
1909 – 1974

Susan Manin Smith
1937 –

Teddy Templeton Jr.
1955 – 1975

Also inscribed in the upper left: “15-428.” Could this be a plot number meaning the marker was removed from a cemetery?

The Power of Collaborative Research

I know that the genealogy community is good at these collaborative projects and we appreciate the sense of stewardship that the general contractors have for the marker. Let’s help reunite it with the family and perhaps learn why it ended up at this abandoned property.

Note: Please don’t post information on living persons and don’t contact the descendants or owners directly. Email me at geneabloggers@gmail.com and I’ll pass on contact info to the property owners so they can reach out to the family.

©2014, copyright Thomas MacEntee

1940 US Census – Your Indexing Help Needed!

1940 US Census

FamilySearch.org and its partners will start publishing the 1940 U.S. Federal Census for free on April 2, 2012, the day the census is released by NARA.  FamilySearch.org will also provide digital images to tens of thousands of volunteers to start transcribing the records so they become searchable.

Complete publication of the index will depend on how many volunteers like you can help. Recently, I heard that if 135,000 people help with indexing the 1940 US Census, the project could be finished in one week. Are you in?

Click here to sign up and volunteer your indexing skills.  It’s easy, it’s fun and it is a great way to give back to the genealogy community!

©2011, copyright Thomas MacEntee